Caldwell is represented by the Cougars throughout the college bowling calendar. Bowling fans follow the Cougars through conference dates, travel weekends, and multi-team events. Fans can order personal videos, signed cards and social shout-outs from Cougar athletes who have joined RallyFuel. RallyFuel sells every order at a published price and refunds it in full if it isn't delivered.
Caldwell University competes in NCAA Division II as a member of the Central Atlantic Collegiate Conference (CACC). The Cougars are based in Caldwell, New Jersey, and sponsor 15 varsity teams. Athletics moved from the NAIA to NCAA Division II during the presidency of Sister Patrice Werner (1994-2009).
The George R. Newman Center seats 1,800 and is home to men's and women's basketball and women's volleyball. Soccer and softball share Caldwell University Athletics Field, lacrosse plays at Essex Valley Field, and baseball plays at Kiwanis Oval.
Caldwell women's soccer has had a graduate move into professional play. Melissa Martinez, a 2025 graduate and Second Team All-CACC forward with 14 goals and 10 assists over two seasons, signed with Næstved HG, a professional club in Denmark, after her time with the Cougars.